Grandparent Custody Rights During Divorce

Key Points

Grandparents don't have rights the way parents do. What they have is standing, meaning permission to ask, and in most states that permission only opens up when the family is already legally fractured. A divorce filing is one of the events that opens it.

Visitation and custody are two completely different requests with two completely different burdens. Asking for regular time with a grandchild is difficult. Asking to be given custody instead of a fit parent is close to impossible, and it should be.

Troxel v. Granville sets the ceiling nationwide. Parents have a fundamental due process right to direct their children's upbringing, fit parents are presumed to act in their children's best interest, and a court has to give real weight to what the parent decided rather than substituting its own view.

In Louisiana, Civil Code article 136 lets a grandparent seek visitation when the parents aren't married, aren't cohabitating as married persons, or have filed a petition for divorce. The article then tells the judge to consider only five factors, and the first one on the list is the parent's constitutional right.

Custody to a non-parent in Louisiana requires proof under article 133 that giving either parent custody would cause the child substantial harm. Not that you'd do a better job. Substantial harm.

Most grandparent time gets arranged inside a parent's custodial period without any court order at all. That's usually the better outcome and almost always the cheaper one.

I get this call pretty often, usually from a grandmother, usually in the first weeks after her son or daughter's marriage falls apart. The facts vary. The question doesn't. They've cut me off. Can I do something?

The honest answer is: sometimes, and less than you'd hope, and it depends heavily on which parent is doing the cutting off and why.

Start by Naming What You're Actually Asking For

People use "grandparent rights" to describe two requests that have almost nothing in common legally.

The first is visitation. You want scheduled, enforceable time with your grandchild. The child still lives with a parent. You're asking the court to carve out a small piece of that parent's authority and hand it to you.

The second is custody. You want the child to live with you, either because both parents are unable to care for the child or because you believe one of them is dangerous. You're asking the court to displace a parent.

Courts treat these very differently, and if you walk into a consultation without knowing which one you want, you'll waste the first half hour. Roughly speaking, visitation cases turn on the quality of the existing relationship and the reasonableness of the parent's refusal. Custody cases turn on evidence of harm, and they're really dependency cases wearing a family law jacket.

Why Divorce Is the Moment the Door Opens

Before 2000, a number of states had wide-open statutes letting anyone petition for visitation whenever a judge thought it might serve the child. Washington had one of the broadest, and the Supreme Court struck down its application in Troxel. The Court held that a fit parent's decision about who sees the child gets a presumption of correctness, and that a trial judge can't simply weigh grandparent time against parental preference as though the two sides start even.

States rewrote their statutes afterward. Almost all of them now require some triggering event before a grandparent can even file: the death of a parent, a divorce or separation, the parents never having married, incarceration, or a finding that the parents are unfit. This is why the divorce filing matters so much. It's often the legal event that gives you standing you didn't have the week before.

Louisiana is a clean example of how this works. Under article 136, a grandparent may be granted visitation if the parents aren't married, aren't cohabitating in the manner of married persons, or have filed a petition for divorce. If the parents are married and haven't filed, article 136 doesn't apply to you at all, and you're looking instead at Louisiana Revised Statute 9:344, which is much narrower. That statute covers situations where a parent has died, been interdicted, or been incarcerated, plus cases where married parents have lived apart for six months and extraordinary circumstances exist. The statute names one such circumstance outright: a court finding that a parent is abusing a controlled dangerous substance.

So the practical rule in Louisiana, and something close to it in most states, is that an intact marriage is a wall. A divorce filing is a door.

What a Judge Is Actually Weighing

Article 136(D) is unusually direct. It tells the court to consider only five factors, which is worth reading closely because it means everything else you want to say is legally irrelevant:

The parent's fundamental constitutional right to make decisions about the care, custody, and control of their own children, and the traditional presumption that a fit parent acts in the child's best interest.
The length and quality of the prior relationship between the child and the relative.
Whether the child needs guidance, enlightenment, or tutelage that the relative can best provide.
The child's preference, if the child is mature enough to express one.
The mental and physical health of the child and the relative.

Notice what's not on that list. Your relationship with your own adult child isn't there. Whether the daughter-in-law is a difficult person isn't there. Whose fault the divorce was isn't there. Judges are human and they hear all of it anyway, but the statute is telling you where the case is won: factor two. Length and quality of the relationship, proven with specifics.

That means school pickups you handled for three years. The summers the child spent at your house. Photographs with dates. The pediatrician who can say you brought the child to appointments. A teacher who knows your name because you were the emergency contact. Vague testimony that you love the child deeply is worth almost nothing, because every grandparent in the courthouse says the same thing on the same day.

Louisiana also requires a hearing under R.S. 9:345 before the court rules, to decide whether the child should have an attorney appointed. Expect it. It adds time and it adds a professional whose only loyalty is to the child, which cuts both ways.

The Custody Question, and Why It's So Hard

If you're asking for custody rather than visitation, Louisiana article 133 sets the bar: custody goes to a non-parent only if an award of joint or sole custody to either parent would result in substantial harm to the child. Once you clear that threshold, the court prefers a person with whom the child has already been living in a wholesome and stable environment, which is often a grandparent. But you have to clear the threshold first, and best interest analysis doesn't even begin until you do.

Most states use a comparable standard, phrased as unfitness, detriment, or harm. It exists for a reason. A rule that let judges compare households and pick the better one would mean any grandparent with a bigger house and a steadier income could take a child from a working single parent. That isn't a system anyone wants.

What clears the bar in practice is documented, ongoing danger. Substance abuse with incidents attached to it. Neglect findings. Criminal conduct involving the child. A parent who has effectively abandoned the child to you and now wants them back for reasons having more to do with child support than parenting. What doesn't clear it: messiness, poverty, a new partner you dislike, or a parenting style that isn't yours.

The Part Nobody Wants to Hear

A large share of grandparent visitation suits filed during a divorce are proxy wars. One side's parents are financing the litigation, sitting in the gallery, and now filing their own petition. Judges see this constantly and they are not fooled by it.

If your petition looks like a second front in your child's divorce, three things happen. The other parent digs in harder. The court's sympathy drains away. And the child, who is the only person in the building with no lawyer of their own, absorbs another round of adult conflict. Research on children of divorce keeps landing on the same finding, which is that ongoing conflict between the adults predicts worse outcomes more reliably than the divorce itself. Adding a third party to the fight is not neutral.

There's also a strategic cost. If you sue the parent who currently controls access, you have converted an informal relationship into an adversarial one, permanently. Even if you win a schedule, you now see the child on court-ordered terms with a parent who resents you. That's a real outcome, and for some families it's the right one. Go in with your eyes open about what it costs.

What Usually Works Better

Before anyone files anything, ask your own adult child to build grandparent time into their custodial schedule. If your son has the children every other weekend, nothing prevents him from spending Saturday afternoons at your house. No court order required, no filing fee, no standing problem. This is how the overwhelming majority of grandparent time actually happens after a divorce, and it's the version that doesn't cost anyone $8,000.

If the relationship with the custodial parent has broken down, try mediation before litigation. A short written agreement about holidays and a monthly weekend, signed and made part of the parenting plan, is enforceable and infinitely less damaging than a contested hearing.

And if you're the parent on the other side of this, reading it with your jaw tight: consider whether the cutoff is protecting your child or punishing your ex. Sometimes it's clearly the former, and you have every right to hold that line. But if what your mother-in-law did was take your husband's side in the divorce, that's a grievance between adults. Your child lost a household this year. Losing a grandmother on top of it is a separate injury, and one you control.

This article is general information about family law and is not legal advice. Grandparent visitation and non-parent custody statutes vary substantially from state to state, and the standards described here are drawn from Louisiana law. Talk to an attorney licensed where your case would be filed.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do grandparents have automatic visitation rights when their child gets divorced? No. There's no automatic right anywhere in the United States. What a divorce filing typically gives a grandparent is standing to petition, which is permission to ask a court. In Louisiana, Civil Code article 136 grants that standing when the parents aren't married, aren't cohabitating as married persons, or have filed for divorce. Standing is the beginning of the case, not the end of it.

Can a grandparent get custody instead of a parent during a divorce? Only by proving that placing the child with either parent would cause substantial harm. Louisiana article 133 uses that exact standard, and most states use something similar. Showing that your home is calmer, cleaner, or better funded isn't enough and isn't supposed to be. These cases succeed on documented danger, not comparison.

What if the parent cutting me off is my own son or daughter? The analysis doesn't change based on which side of the family you're on, but the practical picture does. Suing your own child during their divorce tends to end relationships. Before filing, exhaust the informal route, including asking a mutual family member or a mediator to broker a schedule. The law is available. It's rarely the first tool worth reaching for.

Does it matter that I helped raise the child? Yes, and it may be the single most important fact in a visitation case. The length and quality of the prior relationship is one of the five factors a Louisiana court is permitted to consider. If the child lived with you, if you provided daily care, or if you were the person handling school and medical appointments, gather the records that prove it. Dated photographs, school forms listing you as a contact, and third-party witnesses matter far more than testimony about how much you love the child.

Can grandparent visitation be denied even if the grandparent is loving and stable? Yes. That's what Troxel means. A fit parent gets a presumption that their decision serves the child, and a judge isn't allowed to override it just because grandparent time would also be nice. The parent doesn't have to prove you're harmful. You have to overcome the presumption that the parent's judgment was sound.

How much does a grandparent visitation case cost? It varies widely by market and by how contested the case is, but a fully litigated grandparent visitation matter is a real piece of litigation with pleadings, discovery, possible child interviews, and a trial. Budget accordingly, and ask any attorney you consult for a candid assessment of your odds before you commit. A good one will tell you when the case isn't worth filing.

About the Author

Giacomo Castrogivanni Family Law Attorney

Giacomo Castrogiovanni is the principal of Castrogiovanni Law, Orleans Legal, LLC in Metairie, Louisiana. Born and raised in New Orleans, he earned his B.A. from the University of New Orleans and his J.D. from Loyola University New Orleans College of Law. His practice covers family law, criminal defense, and personal injury. He serves as Staff Attorney for Loyola's Stuart H. Smith Law Clinic and Center for Social Justice, works as a Conflict Panel attorney with the Orleans Parish Public Defender's Office, and teaches Paralegal Studies at Delgado Community College. He is a member of the New Orleans, Jefferson Parish, and American Bar Associations.

About Giacomo

< Older Post